E-Mountainbike comparison testFrom Bosch to DJI - who will build the best E-MTB in 2026?

On the climbs, the candidates from Cannondale (at the front) to Santa Cruz have to prove whether they have more to offer than just motor power.
Photo: Max Fuchs
Downhill fun, full range and balanced riding characteristics. We asked seven top-class e-mountainbikes from Canyon to Cannondale with Bosch or DJI motors to take part in a comparison test. Which candidate can really best fulfil the diverse requirements?

Topics in this article

Is the Transition Regulator CX still an all-mountain bike? This question was more hotly debated during the test phase than vegan substitutes in the meat counter. The pure facts clearly speak in favour: full suspension, 150 to 160 millimetres of travel, mullet tyres - so it fits perfectly into the all-mountain category.

This makes our test group look very homogeneous, as the other six high-end e-mountainbikes also fulfil this requirement profile - in addition, all candidates remain under the 10,000 euro limit we set. With such an experienced test crew, there should be clarity under these circumstances. So why the discussion?

Transition Regulator CX XT / 21.6 kg / 160/150 mm / 29/27.5" / 9990 Euro / Carbon
Photo: Max Fuchs
The test group at a glance.

The test articles of all candidates at a glance

All Mountain - a question of definition

It's not the key data that gets our tempers flaring, but a fundamental question: What should a real all-mountain bike be capable of? This is precisely where fact-based pigeonholing reaches its limits. Because by definition, this type of bike goes over all mountains - the name says it all. Long days in the saddle, many metres in altitude, technical trails: True to the motto "the journey is the destination", all-mountain bikes should take the work out of both uphill and downhill terrain and offer safety without pushing the rider out of their comfort zone. Ideally, the bike itself is the comfort zone.

Most read articles

1

2

3

The Transition swings round the bends like a Nissan Skyline from Fast & Furious with Paul Walker on the accelerator. This puts it right at the top of Max's list of favourites.Photo: Laurin LehnerThe Transition swings round the bends like a Nissan Skyline from Fast & Furious with Paul Walker on the accelerator. This puts it right at the top of Max's list of favourites.

If you take a closer look at the Regulator CX through this lens, the all-mountain façade begins to crumble. Taking work off uphill? Not a chance. Even if the climbing characteristics are impressive, maximum range is not in the specification with the small, fully integrated 600 Wh battery. The Santa Cruz Vala also relies on this drive concept - and requires disciplined energy management on long tours. With 800 watt hours and more in the down tube, the competition simply has more staying power on long mountain tours and is better suited to the requirements of an all-mountain bike.

How do you like this article?

Does weight (not) play a role?

BIKE measured value: Weight without pedals. Battery weight incl. cover if applicable. Wheel weight per set with tyres, cassette, brake discs. Wheel inertia: The lower the measured value, the better.Photo: BIKE GrafikBIKE measured value: Weight without pedals. Battery weight incl. cover if applicable. Wheel weight per set with tyres, cassette, brake discs. Wheel inertia: The lower the measured value, the better.

"But the small batteries reduce the weight", you might think. And our laboratory scales confirm it: the Transition weighs just 21.62 kilos - a whole 2730 grams less than the heaviest candidate, the Cannondale Moterra 1 with removable 800 Wh battery. Those who accept the shorter range will be rewarded with a natural, lively downhill ride. Whether you prefer the light handling of the Transition or glide comfortably down the valley on the heavy Cannondale like on a maglev train is a matter of taste - both convey riding confidence in their own way. All-mountain feeling with the Transition? Of course!

Rotwild and Crussis clearly miss the 20-kilo mark. In other words, even bikes with a DJI motor can't do magic when it comes to weight. - Hans-Peter Ettenberger, BIKE test laboratory

The motors in the test

With the coveted DJI Avinox on one side and the old Shimano EP801 on the other, the test offers an exciting mix. Bosch provides the reference.

Bosch Performance CX: Since the CX Gen5, the Bosch is rattle-free downhill and has also increased its performance. 750 watts and 100 Nm are now possible. The EMTB+ mode is unrivalled uphill from our point of view, the range is really strong. Not super light, but otherwise hard to beat.
Photo: Max Fuchs

The reach height

How far does a battery charge go? This question can hardly be answered in general terms because many different factors - above all the rider's weight - influence the actual range. At BIKE, we therefore calculate comparable values in an extensive practical test with a rider weight of 90 kilos and a constant 150 watts of pedalling power with full support on a steep asphalt road. This gives us an ideal basis for comparison.

Striking: Bosch is still hard to beat in terms of range. Both the 800 and the small 600 batteries deliver many metres in altitude per nominal watt hour. The value of the 800 Bosch is only surpassed by real specialists with 900 watt hours and more. As the DJI is driven with full support, it climbs extremely quickly and clearly outperforms the Bosch in terms of average speed. At equalised speed, the 800 DJI is just behind the Bosch in the Crussis. Rotwild's 864 battery is strong and should reach the level of the large Bosch batteries at equalised speed. The Shimano in the Canyon rides comfortably, smoothly and is also quick on the climbs. However, the new 800cc battery falls noticeably short of the best values of the 900cc battery of its predecessor (2200 m / 14 km/h).

BIKE measured value: Reach height determined during test rides on asphalt with a gradient of 12.2 per cent. Highest support level, 150 watts rider power, rider weight 90 kg.Photo: BIKE GrafikBIKE measured value: Reach height determined during test rides on asphalt with a gradient of 12.2 per cent. Highest support level, 150 watts rider power, rider weight 90 kg.
Even in the pre-series, the lightweight exchangeable battery in the Rotwild delivers strong range values on a par with Bosch's 800 battery. - Adrian Kaether, BIKE Editor

DJI - the game changer?

But what if one does not exclude the other? When long range and low weight go hand in hand? This is where the competitors from Rotwild and Crussis come into play. Both rely on the coveted DJI Avinox drive. The first models with the supposedly miraculous power unit impressed with weights of around 20 kilos despite their berserk power (1000 watts) and large 800 Wh batteries. Unfortunately, our test bikes do not reach these spheres. At 21.94 kilos, the Crussis is only just behind the Transition in second place in terms of weight. In this weight class, both bikes shine with their natural, light-footed handling.

Dry and warm - the trails around Finale Ligure offered the ideal conditions for testing the high-end eMTBs in winter. The photos were taken around the famous Madonna della Guardia and on the challenging Legnino Uphill (pictured). We tested the trail classics Pino Morto and Oribago 2 as well as the Scogliera Uphill, which was created for the Enduro World Cup.Photo: Max FuchsDry and warm - the trails around Finale Ligure offered the ideal conditions for testing the high-end eMTBs in winter. The photos were taken around the famous Madonna della Guardia and on the challenging Legnino Uphill (pictured). We tested the trail classics Pino Morto and Oribago 2 as well as the Scogliera Uphill, which was created for the Enduro World Cup.

But one crucial difference remains: With the Crussis, the low weight is not at the expense of range. While the Transition has to make compromises here due to the 600 watt battery, the Crussis, with 800 watt hours in the battery, lasts a long time even on extended tours.

We can now finally put a tick behind our discussion: No, the Transition is not an all-mountain bike, at least not a thoroughbred one. Our detailed test explains why the bike still scores top marks and why the Bosch bikes ultimately beat the DJI models.

The test results

CategoryWeighting in %CannondaleTransitionCrussisSanta CruzRed deerStevensCanyon
Pricein Euro-8799999989908699999078995999
DRIVING CONDUCTUphill201,522,53,52,534
Play instinct123,51,522,533,52,5
Downhill1222,531,5423
Chassis161,52,52,521,53,53
Driving behaviour grade602,002,132,502,502,633,033,23
MOTORPower71,51,50,51,50,51,52
Driving behaviour51,251,251,751,251,751,252,5
Operation31,752,51,52,51,522,5
Note Motor151,471,621,121,621,121,522,27
LABORATORYTotal weight53,251,251,51,752,252,752,75
Reach512,51,52,5111,75
Note Lab102,131,881,502,131,631,882,25
EQUIPMENTEquipment quality31,51,91,12,4322,281,08
Usability / added value33,753,543,252,7533,75
Transport volume bottle cage333,5433,533
Shipping / parcel30,50,53,50,542,52,5
Value / processing30,50,51,51,50,51,51,5
Equipment grade151,951,982,822,142,552,462,37
SERVICEWarranty (years)-5for life2for life566
Service friendliness-mediumWeakgoodWeakmediummediummedium
TOTALBIKE NOTE1001,932,012,242,282,292,602,86

Conclusion from Max Fuchs

Max Fuchs is test editor and photographer at BIKE.Photo: Moonhead MediaMax Fuchs is test editor and photographer at BIKE.
The high-priced all-mountain segment is a highly competitive field - especially this year, when DJI bikes took part in the comparison test of high-end e-mountainbikes for the first time. However, the initial hype surrounding the exciting power unit from China died down during the test. Although the Crussis with DJI is a front runner, the motor alone does not guarantee a test victory. That was secured by the Cannondale with its Bosch system and outstanding all-round qualities. - Max Fuchs, test editor and photographer at BIKE

Adrian Kaether's favourite thing to do is ride mountain bikes on bumpy enduro trails. The tech expert and bike tester knows all about Newton metres and watt hours, high and low-speed damping. As test manager at MYBIKE, Adrian also likes to think outside the box and tests cargo bikes and step-through bikes as well as the latest (e-)MTBs.

Most read in category Components